Buying a house in Ohio, especially in a competitive market like Cincinnati, is one of the biggest financial decisions you’ll ever make. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer exploring first time home buyer programs or an experienced investor looking for prime listings, having the right Cincinnati real estate agents by your side can make all the difference.
Like many cities in OH, Cincinnati has a complicated real estate market. The process of buying or selling a home in Cincinnati involves navigating market trends, understanding key zip codes, and ensuring you have expert guidance to make the best decisions.
Cincinnati OH real estate agents specialize in different areas, from luxury homes in Indian Hill to trendy condos in Over-the-Rhine, as well as suburban properties in West Chester. A great realtor in Cincinnati will not only know the city’s diverse neighborhoods, but will also help buyers and sellers streamline their search, negotiate deals, and handle every step of the process. With the right agent, you can confidently tackle the market, whether you’re on the search for the perfect home or selling your property.
In this guide, we’ll highlight the best Cincinnati real estate agents to help you find the perfect fit for your real estate journey in the city. Whether you’re buying, selling, or just starting your search, these professionals can help you navigate the city’s real estate landscape with confidence.
Who Are the Top Cincinnati Real Estate Agents?
When selling or buying a house in Cincinnati, it’s important to do a search for the best Cincinnati real estate agents. You’ll want to make sure you read reviews and check out popular listings to help you find a professional who knows the market inside and out. A good real estate agent in Cincinnati will have a great understanding of the zip codes in the city, helping to simplify the process of helping you find a new home. These are a few of the best Cincinnati real estate agents.
1. Matt Hester
When it comes to Cincinnati real estate agents, Matt Hester is the best of the best. This realtor in Cincinnati is with Harry Norman Realtors and has been in the industry for over 12 years. In the past 12 months, he has completed 376 sales, and the price of sales over the past 12 months is somewhere between $350,234 and $583,723.
2. Tami Holmes
View this post on Instagram
Tami Holmes is one of the best Cincinnati real estate agents and operates under Corcoran Global Living. As one of the top agents in Cincinnati, Tami has made 271 sales over the past 12 months. Tami primarily serves Dayton, Troy, and Cincinnati and has a deep understanding of these markets. She is the founder and CEO of the Tami Holmes Team, which has sold over $580 million in real estate, translating into over 3,300 homes sold.
3. Scott Oyler
Licensed in both Ohio and Kentucky, Scott Oyler is one of the best Cincinnati real estate agents. Scott knows the market well and is experienced in the Cincinnati area as well as surrounding townships like West Chester. Throughout his time in the industry, Scott has exceeded $1 billion in sales, placing him in the top 1% of all Coldwell Banker agents internationally. Scott is the team lead of Oyler Hines, which is one of the top real estate teams in Cincinnati. The team serves both sides of the Ohio River and is experienced in both Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky real estate.
4. Kimberly Mansfield
View this post on Instagram
One of the best Cincinnati real estate agents, Kimberly Mansfield is the leader of the KimTimTeam, whose top agents have over 75 years of combined experience in the real estate business. The team serves the entire Cincinnati area but specializes in the Milford, Goshen, and Loveland neighborhoods. In 2023, the KimTimTeam achieved a sales volume of over $28 million and sold 101 homes. Kim herself sold 76 homes with an average sale price of over $300,000.
5. Beth Brown Ciul
If you’re searching for the best Cincinnati real estate agents, Beth Brown Ciul should be at the top of your list. Licensed in 2002, Beth Brown Ciul is an expert at negotiating the best price, finding the perfect homes, and getting the deal done. Beth has extra knowledge of the industry, as she spent 10 years as a paralegal specializing in probate and estates.
Beth is with eXp Realty and has spent her entire career in the Greater Cincinnati and Dayton real estate market. She now heads The Cornerstone Home Group and is an instructor at one of the leading real estate educational organizations in Ohio.
6. John Bowen
If you’re looking for Cincinnati real estate agents who specialize in finding the best homes in the area, then look no further than John Bowen. John can assist with everything from buying a home, selling a home or securing a home mortgage. He is with Re/Max and received his Bachelor’s and MBA from the University of Cincinnati.
With almost nine years of experience in the real estate industry, John will help you navigate the process from start to finish. In 2023, John made 57 sales ranging from $223,000 to $373,000.
7. Lisa McCarthy
View this post on Instagram
Lisa McCarthy is a realtor in Cincinnati with Coldwell Banker. Lisa has been licensed since 2005 and was awarded the Circle of Excellence award in 2007, 2010, and 2013-2024. She was also awarded the Coldwell Banker Realty President’s Elite award from 2012-2019 and then again in 2024.
Lisa heads the Lisa McCarthy Group, a top-performing team of Cincinnati real estate agents assisting customers in and around the Cincinnati area.
8. Jenny Young
When it comes to Cincinnati real estate agents, Jenny Young is one of the best. Licensed since 2003, this realtor in Cincinnati specializes in residential properties in several zip codes, servicing Cincinnati, Mason, West Chester, Florence, KY, and beyond. She is a Certified Residential Specialist (CRS), a Relocation Specialist, a New Construction Specialist, an Accredited Buyer Representative (ABR), and a Senior Residential Specialist (SRES).
Jenny works under Century 21 and has completed 41 sales in the past 12 months.
9. Maryann Ries
View this post on Instagram
Working with Comey & Shepherd Realtors, Maryann Ries is one of the best Cincinnati real estate agents. As one of the best Cincinnati real estate experts, Maryann made 38 sales over the past 12 months, ranging from $373,000 to $622,000. Maryann serves both Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky.
10. Sara Foltz
With Keller Williams Realty, Sara Foltz is one of the best Cincinnati real estate agents and will help you with your journey of buying or selling your home. She is licensed in both Ohio and Kentucky and has been a full-time realtor since 2006.
Sara heads The Foltz Team, which has a 100% customer satisfaction rate and currently has 325 properties on the market.
What Are the Top Real Estate Teams in Cincinnati OH?
When moving to Cincinnati, you may also want to find experienced teams and real estate agencies in Cincinnati. A Cincinnati real estate team is a group of two or more Cincinnati real estate agents who work together on one transaction or team up and use each other’s resources.
Finding a realtor in Cincinnati who works in a top-rated real estate team can be very beneficial. These teams know the market inside and out and can help you find homes in many different zip codes. From Downtown Cincinnati to West Chester, these are the best real estate teams in Cincinnati.
1. The Chabris Group
The Chabris Group is a top team of Cincinnati real estate agents with Keller Williams. The team has broken records with a sales volume of $103.8 million and 389 transaction sides.
2. Oyler Hines
View this post on Instagram
With a sales volume of $180.3 million and 322 sides in 2023, Oyler Hines knows the market inside and out. Operating under Coldwell Banker Realty, Oyler Hines has won numerous awards for their service in the area.
3. The Baron Group
The team of Cincinnati real estate agents at The Baron Group serves Cincinnati, Northern Kentucky, and Dayton and ranks in the top 1% of realtors, with nearly $250 million sold. They are 5-time winners of the CABR Circle of Excellence and operate under Keller Williams.
4. Close To Home Consultants
Close to Home Consultants is a top-producing real estate team with KW Advisors. Their sales volume in 2023 was $45.4 million, and they have 161 transaction sides.
5. Team Herr
Team Herr is a professional team of Cincinnati real estate agents and is ranked in the top 1.5% of all real estate professionals in the country by RealTrends. With over $70 million in sales volume and 161 transaction sides, Team Herr is the best of the best.
What Are the Best Brokerages in Cincinnati?
A real estate brokerage is a firm in the city where a team of Cincinnati real estate agents and brokers operate. Together, they help buyers search the market, buy, sell, and manage properties. In a real estate brokerage, agents are typically entry-level professionals who rely on brokers for oversight throughout the process.
Oftentimes, brokers establish their own brokerage firm, hire agents, and offer training and marketing resources. In return for their services, they take a percentage of the agent’s commission.
These are the top brokerages in Cincinnati, ranked by sales volume and transaction sides.
|
Top Cincinnati Real Estate Agencies Top Brokerages by Transaction Sides in 2023 |
||||
| Brokerage | State Rank | Location | Transaction Sides | Sales Volume |
| Sibcy Cline, Inc. | 3 | Cincinnati | 4,679 | $1.8 billion |
| Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices | 6 | Mason | 5,603 | $1.5 billion |
| Comey and Shepherd | 10 | Cincinnati | 3,630 | $1.1 billion |
| RE/MAX Unlimited | 15 | Cincinnati | 5,665 | $880 million |
| ERA Real Solutions Realty | 24 | Cincinnati | 1,453 | $484.1 million |
| Keller Williams Community Partners | 25 | Miamisburg | 2,012 | $483.8 million |
| Keller Williams Montgomery, OH | 31 | Cincinnati | 1,437 | $440.3 million |
| KW Seven Hills | 33 | Cincinnati | 1,394 | $383 million |
View this post on Instagram
What Are the Largest Cincinnati Real Estate Brokerages?
Are you curious about the team with the most Cincinnati real estate agents? When buying or selling a house, you may want to choose a team that handles hundreds of listings, ensuring expertise and knowledge about the city.
Here are the largest real estate companies in Cincinnati based on 2023 local home sales volume:
- Coldwell Banker Realty-Ohio: 1,102 local agents with $2.46 billion in local home sales
- Comey and Shepherd Realtors: 610 local agents with $1.94 billion in local home sales
- Sibcy Cline Inc: 645 local agents with $1.66 billion in local home sales
- Huff Realty: 437 local agents with $1.05 billion in local home sales
- Keller Williams Advisors Realty: 363 local agents with $852 million in local home sales
View this post on Instagram
FAQs About Cincinnati Real Estate Companies
Who Is the Top Realtor in Cincinnati?
In terms of the best Cincinnati real estate agents, Matt Hester tops the list. He is the top-performing realtor in Cincinnati, with plenty of experience under his belt.
How Much Do Realtors Make in Cincinnati?
Cincinnati real estate agents generally take a commission of 5% to 6% of the sales price.
Is Cincinnati Real Estate Slowing Down?
The Cincinnati real estate market is actually picking up. According to Redfin, housing prices in Cincinnati are up 7.9% compared to last year. The median home price in Cincinnati is $259,000.
Is It Better to Hire a Real Estate Agent in Cincinnati?
Yes, hiring Cincinnati real estate agents ensures a smooth and stress-free process.
Ready to Work With a Top Rated Realtor in Cincinnati?
Now that you know all of the best Cincinnati real estate agents, it’s time to choose a realtor in Cincinnati that fits your needs. The Cincinnati movers at Bell Moving & Storage are ready to help you get settled into your new Cincinnati home. To discuss your move and get started with a free estimate, give our team a call at (513) 942-7500.
